Question

I’m learning C# coming from C++ and have run into a wall.

I have an abstract class AbstractWidget, an interface IDoesCoolThings, and a class which derives from AbstractWidget called RealWidget:

public interface IDoesCoolThings {     void DoCool(); }  public abstract class AbstractWidget : IDoesCoolThings {     void IDoesCoolThings.DoCool()     {         Console.Write('I did something cool.');     } }  public class RealWidget : AbstractWidget {  } 

When I instantiate a RealWidget object and call DoCool() on it, the compiler gives me an error saying

‘RealWidget’ does not contain a definition for ‘DoCool’

I can cast RealWidget object to an IDoesCoolThings and then the call will work, but that seems unnecessary and I also lose polymorphism (AbstractWidget.DoCool() will always be called even if i define RealWidget.DoCool()).

I imagine the solution is simple, but I’ve tried a variety of things and for the life of me can’t figure this one out.

Answer 1

You’re running into the issue because you used explicit interface implementation (EII). When a member is explicitly implemented, it can’t be accessed through a class instance — only through an instance of the interface. In your example, that’s why you can’t call DoCool() unless you cast your instance to IDoesCoolThings.

The solution is to make DoCool() public and remove the explicit interface implementation:

public abstract class AbstractWidget : IDoesCoolThings {     public void DoCool()      // DoCool() is part of the abstract class implementation.     {         Console.Write('I did something cool.');     } }  // ...  var rw = new RealWidget(); rw.DoCool();                  // Works! 

In general, you use EII in two cases:

• You have a class that must implement two interfaces, each of which contains a member that has an identical name/signature to another member in the other interface.
• You want to force clients not to depend on the implementation details of your class, but rather on the interface that’s being implemented by your class. (This is considered a good practice by some.)