Question

I’m looking at an example of a save method in a Products repository from Steven Sanderson’s book, Pro ASP.NET MVC 2 Framework:

public void SaveProduct(Product product)
{
    // if new product, attach to DataContext:
    if (product.ProductID == 0)
        productsTable.InsertOnSubmit(product);
    else if (productsTable.GetOriginalEntityState(product) == null)
    { 
        // we're updating existing product
        productsTable.Attach(product);
        productsTable.Context.Refresh(RefreshMode.KeepCurrentValues, product);
    }
    productsTable.Context.SubmitChanges();            
}

I do not understand the logic in the else if line:

else if (productsTable.GetOriginalEntityState(product) == null)

As I understand it, GetOriginalEntityState() returns the original state of the specified entity.. in this case that entity is product.

So this else if statement reads to me like: “If an original doesn’t exist then…” but that doesn’t make sense because the book is saying that this checks that we are modifying a record that already DOES exist.

How should I understand GetOriginalEntityState in this context?

Edit

By the way, this excerpt came from chapter 6, page 191… just in case anyone has the book and wants to look it up. The book just has that function in the code sample but it never explains what the function does.

Answer 1

This is a little bit of a guess since I have never actually used GetOriginalEntityState but the question peaked my interest to figure out what is going on.

I think the intent here is to check that product is still attached to the original DataContext

The line:

if (productsTable.GetOriginalEntityState(product) == null) 

I think this will return null if product has been dettached or created manually and not handled by the DataContext.

From MSDN:

This method returns the original state
of an entity since it was either
created or attached to the current
DataContext. The original state of an
entity that has been serialized and
deserialized must be provided by an
independent tracking mechanism and
supplied when the entity is attached
to a new DataContext. For more
information, see Data Retrieval and
CUD Operations in N-Tier Applications
(LINQ to SQL).

I think the key line to understand is:

This method returns the original state
of an entity since it was either
created or attached to the current
DataContext.

GetOriginalEntityState is used so that the method can receive an object with the option of not being attached already to the DataContext. Attached meaning, returned by a Linq To SQL call vs just creating an instance like Product p = new Product() { ... };. If it is not attached, it will attach it to the DataContext and keep any of the values that were modified (preserving the update values) due to the RefreshMode.KeepCurrentValues param.

Then the productsTable.Context.SubmitChanges(); always happens since even if it is dettached, the GetOriginalEntityState will make sure it gets attached so the submit will work.