Question

I’m trying to set up a stub with Rhino Mocks which returns a value based on what the parameter of the argument that is passed in.

Example:

//Arrange
var car = new Car();
var provider= MockRepository.GenerateStub<IDataProvider>();
provider.Stub(
    x => x.GetWheelsWithSize(Arg<int>.Is.Anything))
    .Return(new List<IWheel> {
                new Wheel { Size = ?, Make = Make.Michelin },
                new Wheel { Size = ?, Make = Make.Firestone }
            });

car.Provider = provider;

//Act
car.ReplaceTires();

//Assert that the right tire size was used when replacing the tires

The problem is that I want Size to be whatever was passed into the method, because I’m actually asserting later that the wheels are the right size. This is not to prove that the data provider works obviously since I stubbed it, but rather to prove that the correct size was passed in.

How can I do this?

Answer 1

“This is not to prove that the data provider works … but rather to prove that
the correct size was passed in.”

Not sure if it works that well for this particular case, but generally I’ve found it easiest to test these sorts of things indirectly via the stub.

Rather than checking the output of the stubbed call, explicitly specify the arguments to your stub and then verify that the return value was used as expected (regardless of the actual data returned). If it was, then you know that your stub was called correctly.

//Arrange
var wheels = new List<IWheel>();
const int wheelSize = 17;
var car = new Car();
car.WheelSize = wheelSize;
var provider= MockRepository.GenerateStub<IDataProvider>();
provider
    .Stub(x => x.GetWheelsWithSize(wheelSize))
    .Return(wheels);    
car.Provider = provider;

//Act
car.ReplaceTires();

//Assert that the right-sized wheels from the provider were
//used when replacing the tires
Assert.That(car.Wheels, Is.SameAs(wheels));

If this approach doesn’t work for you in this case then you can use WhenCalled to inspect the call arguments and/or modify the return value.

provider
    .Stub(x => x.GetWheelsWithSize(Arg<int>.Is.Anything))
    .WhenCalled(x => x.ReturnValue = CreateWheelsOfSize((int) x.Arguments[0]));  

In this case CreateWheelsOfSize(int) will just create your list of wheels.

Hope this helps.