In a listbox, when I select an item I still get some kind of border or space around my listboxitem creating the line you see in the image. I want to remove that line I put a circle around.
It already has HorizontalContentAlignment = "Stretch" by the way.
What am I doing wrong?
The problem:

Matt’s right, in that it’s sort of a bug. The padding is hard coded in the ListBox template, rather than being tied to a property you can change.
Best way to fix this is to redefine the template, like so: