In which cases storing data as XML is preferable to RDBMS and why?
Can you give any analogy?
Share
Sign Up to our social questions and Answers Engine to ask questions, answer people’s questions, and connect with other people.
Login to our social questions & Answers Engine to ask questions answer people’s questions & connect with other people.
Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
In which cases storing data as XML is preferable to RDBMS and why?
Can you give any analogy?
Summary
If you don’t have much data and you’re in total control of it (no dependent 3rd parties), XML is a nice option. Otherwise, RDBMS – see below for more reasons.
Analogy
If RDBMS is a filing cabinet (drawers of same-sized records organized by some index) then XML is a back-pack (not-necessarily-organized bag of randomly-sized records, may stick out at the corners).
Reasons for XML
1) Flexibility
If your schema is either very loose or changes over time, XML is preferable as versioning RDMS is hard once there’s data inside it. In my experience, XML Serialization, XSLT and XPath queries are resilient to changes in the XML schema and can continue to work for old/new clients. For example, you can add some new elements into a document and an older EXE that reads that document will just ignore those elements. An RDBMS query that does ‘SELECT * FROM table’ where you just added a column will have undefined results.
2) Deployment
Easy – just ship your EXE.
3) Debugability
Easy to ‘debug’ the data – the XML could be human-readable already; if not, XSLT may make it more readable.
4) Interoperability
You can hand the XML off to other systems and not care what platform/technology they use.
Reasons for RDBMS
1) Performance
If you have a lot of data, then the indexing features of a RDBMS will give you best performance. Reading a large XML (> 1000 records) is expensive if you’re fundamentally just trying to find the record with ID=123, which RDBMS can do in a snap. Stored Procedures would make this even better.
2) Security
You can secure parts of RDBMS through permissions – e.g. grant/deny SELECT access to various users.
3) Business Tools
There are many RDBMS tools for things such as OLAP and reporting.