I’ve been working on a project that can’t be described as ‘small’ anymore (40+ months), with a team that can’t be defined as ‘small’ anymore (~30 people). We’ve been using Agile/Scrum (1) practices all along, and a healthy dose of TDD.
I’m not sure if I picked this up from Agile or TDD, more likely a combination of the two, but I’m now clearly in the camp of people that looks at debugging as a bad smell. By ‘debugging’ I’m not referring to the more abstract concept of figuring out what might be wrong with the system, but the specific activity of running the system in Debug mode, stepping through the code to figure out details that are otherwise inscrutable.
Since I’m fairly convinced, this question is not about whether debugging is a bad smell or not. Rather, I’d like to know how I can persuade my team-mates about this.
People that believe debugging mode is the ‘standard’ mode tend to write code that can be understood only by debugging through it, which leads to a lot of time wasted since every time you work an item on top of code developed by someone else, you get to first spend a considerable amount of time debugging it (and, since there’s no bug involved.. the term is becoming increasingly ridiculous) – and then silos happen. So I’d love to convince a few of my team-mates that avoiding debug mode is a Good Thing (2). Since they are used to live in Debug mode, however, they don’t seem to see the problem; to them, spending hours debugging someone else code before they even start doing anything related to their new item is the norm; they don’t see anything wrong with it. Plus, as they spend time ‘figuring it out’ they know eventually the developer that worked that area will become available and the item will be passed on to them (leading to yet another silo).
Help me come up with a plan to turn them from the Dark Side !
Thanks in advance.
(1) Also referred to as SCRUM (all caps). Capitalization arguments aside, I think an asterisk after the term must be used since – unsurprisingly – our organization ‘tweaked’ the Agile and Scrum process to fit the perceived needs of all stakeholders involved. So, in all honesty, I won’t pretend this has been 100% according to theory, but that’s beside the point of my question.
(2) Yes, there will always be times when we’ll have to get in debug mode, I’m not trying to absolutely avoid it, just.. trying to minimize the number of times we have to dive into it.
If you want to persuade your coworkers that your programming practices are better, first demonstrate by your productiveness that you are more effective than they are, at least for some tasks. Then they’ll believe you when you explain how you get so much done.
It’s also sometimes easier to focus on something concrete. Do your coworkers even talk in terms of ‘code smell’? Perhaps you could focus on specifics like ‘When the ABC module fails, it takes forever to debug it; it’s much faster to use technique XYZ. Here, let me demonstrate.’ Then afterwards you can mention your basic principle, which is yeah the debugger is a useful tool, but there’s usually other more useful ones.