Question

I’ve been working with providers a fair bit lately, and I came across an interesting situation where I wanted to have an abstract class that had an abstract static method. I read a few posts on the topic, and it sort of made sense, but is there a nice clear explanation?

Answer 1

Static methods are not instantiated as such, they’re just available without an object reference.

A call to a static method is done through the class name, not through an object reference, and the Intermediate Language (IL) code to call it will call the abstract method through the name of the class that defined it, not necessarily the name of the class you used.

Let me show an example.

With the following code:

public class A {     public static void Test()     {     } }  public class B : A { } 

If you call B.Test, like this:

class Program {     static void Main(string[] args)     {         B.Test();     } } 

Then the actual code inside the Main method is as follows:

.entrypoint .maxstack 8 L0000: nop  L0001: call void ConsoleApplication1.A::Test() L0006: nop  L0007: ret  

As you can see, the call is made to A.Test, because it was the A class that defined it, and not to B.Test, even though you can write the code that way.

If you had class types, like in the Delphi Programming Language, where you can make a variable referring to a type and not an object, you would have more use for virtual and thus abstract static methods (and also constructors), but they aren’t available and thus static calls are non-virtual in .NET.

I realize that the IL designers could allow the code to be compiled to call B.Test, and resolve the call at runtime, but it still wouldn’t be virtual, as you would still have to write some kind of class name there.

Virtual methods, and thus abstract ones, are only useful when you’re using a variable which, at runtime, can contain many different types of objects, and you thus want to call the right method for the current object you have in the variable. With static methods you need to go through a class name anyway, so the exact method to call is known at compile time because it can’t and won’t change.

Thus, virtual/abstract static methods are not available in .NET.