Question

I’ve got almost the same question as here.

I have an array which contains aa ab aa ac aa ad, etc.
Now I want to select all unique elements from this array.
Thought, this would be simple with sort | uniq or with sort -u as they mentioned in that other question, but nothing changed in the array…
The code is:

echo `echo "${ids[@]}" | sort | uniq`

What am I doing wrong?

Answer 1

A bit hacky, but this should do it:

echo "${ids[@]}" | tr ' ' '\n' | sort -u | tr '\n' ' '

To save the sorted unique results back into an array, do Array assignment:

sorted_unique_ids=($(echo "${ids[@]}" | tr ' ' '\n' | sort -u | tr '\n' ' '))

If your shell supports herestrings (bash should), you can spare an echo process by altering it to:

tr ' ' '\n' <<< "${ids[@]}" | sort -u | tr '\n' ' '

A note as of Aug 28 2021:

According to ShellCheck wiki 2207 a read -a pipe should be used to avoid splitting.
Thus, in bash the command would be:

IFS=" " read -r -a ids <<< "$(echo "${ids[@]}" | tr ' ' '\n' | sort -u | tr '\n' ' ')"

or

IFS=" " read -r -a ids <<< "$(tr ' ' '\n' <<< "${ids[@]}" | sort -u | tr '\n' ' ')"

Input:

ids=(aa ab aa ac aa ad)

Output:

aa ab ac ad

Explanation:

• "${ids[@]}" – Syntax for working with shell arrays, whether used as part of echo or a herestring. The @ part means "all elements in the array"
• tr ' ' '\n' – Convert all spaces to newlines. Because your array is seen by shell as elements on a single line, separated by spaces; and because sort expects input to be on separate lines.
• sort -u – sort and retain only unique elements
• tr '\n' ' ' – convert the newlines we added in earlier back to spaces.
• $(...) – Command Substitution
• Aside: tr ' ' '\n' <<< "${ids[@]}" is a more efficient way of doing: echo "${ids[@]}" | tr ' ' '\n'