Question

Lets say I have a simple many-to-many table between tables ‘table1’ and ‘table2’ that consists from two int fields: ‘table1-id’ and ‘table2-id’. How should I index this linking table?

I used to just make a composite primary index (table1-id,table2-id), but I read that this index might not work if you change order of the fields in the query. So what’s the optimal solution then – make independent indexes for each field without a primary index?

Thanks.

Answer 1

It depends on how you search.

If you search like this:

/* Given a value from table1, find all related values from table2 */ SELECT * FROM table1 t1 JOIN table_table tt ON (tt.table_1 = t1.id) JOIN table2 t2 ON (t2.id = tt.table_2) WHERE t1.id = @id 

then you need:

ALTER TABLE table_table ADD CONSTRAINT pk_table1_table2 (table_1, table_2) 

In this case, table1 will be leading in NESTED LOOPS and your index will be usable only when table1 is indexed first.

If you search like this:

/* Given a value from table2, find all related values from table1 */ SELECT * FROM table2 t2 JOIN table_table tt ON (tt.table_2 = t2.id) JOIN table1 t1 ON (t1.id = tt.table_1) WHERE t2.id = @id 

then you need:

ALTER TABLE table_table ADD CONSTRAINT pk_table1_table2 (table_2, table_1) 

for the reasons above.

You don’t need independent indices here. A composite index can be used everywhere where a plain index on the first column can be used. If you use independent indices, you won’t be able to search efficiently for both values:

/* Check if relationship exists between two given values */ SELECT 1 FROM table_table WHERE table_1 = @id1   AND table_2 = @id2 

For a query like this, you’ll need at least one index on both columns.

It’s never bad to have an additional index for the second field:

ALTER TABLE table_table ADD CONSTRAINT pk_table1_table2 PRIMARY KEY (table_1, table_2) CREATE INDEX ix_table2 ON table_table (table_2) 

Primary key will be used for searches on both values and for searches based on value of table_1, additional index will be used for searches based on value of table_2.