Question

My team is developing a new service oriented product with a web front-end. In discussions about what technologies we will use we have settled on running a JBoss application server, and Flex frontend (with possible desktop deployment using Adobe AIR), and web services to interface the client and server.

We’ve reached an impasse when it comes to which server technology to use for our business logic. The big argument is between EJB3 and Spring, with our biggest concerns being scalability and performance, and also maintainability of the code base.

Here are my questions:

1. What are the arguments for or against EJB3 vs Spring?
   • What pitfalls can I expect with each?
   • Where can I find good benchmark information?

Answer 1

There won’t be much difference between EJB3 and Spring based on Performance. We chose Spring for the following reasons (not mentioned in the question):

• Spring drives the architecture in a direction that more readily supports unit testing. For example, inject a mock DAO object to unit test your business layer, or utilize Spring’s MockHttpRequest object to unit test a servlet. We maintain a separate Spring config for unit tests that allows us to isolate tests to the specific layers.
• An overriding driver was compatibility. If you need to support more than one App Server (or eventually want the option to move from JBoss to Glassfish, etc.), you will essentially be carrying your container (Spring) with you, rather than relying on compatibility between different implementations of the EJB3 specification.
• Spring allows for technology choices for Persistence, object remoting, etc. For example, we are also using a Flex front end, and are using the Hessian protocol for communications between Flex and Spring.