Question

Ok, so a Windows Forms class, WindowSettings, and the form has a “Cancel”-button. When the user clicks the button, the dialog DialogSettingsCancel will pop-up up and ask the user if he is sure he wants to perform the action. The dialog has 2 buttons, a “Yes”-button and a “No”-button. If the user clicks the “Yes”-button, I want both DialogSettingsCancel and WindowSettings to be closed.

My button_Click event handler in DialogSettingsCancel:

private void button1_Click(object sender, EventArgs e)
{
    //Code to trigger when the "Yes"-button is pressed.
    WindowSettings settings = new WindowSettings();
    this.Close();
    settings.Close();
}

When I run my application, and go to the settings form, and click the “Cancel”-button, and then click the “Yes”-button, only DialogSettingsCancel closes without closing WindowSettings.

Why won’t it work?

I’ve also tried changing

this.Close();
settings.Close();

to

settings.Close();
this.Close();

But still the same result.

Answer 1

You need the actual instance of the WindowSettings that’s open, not a new one.

Currently, you are creating a new instance of WindowSettings and calling Close on that. That doesn’t do anything because that new instance never has been shown.

Instead, when showing DialogSettingsCancel set the current instance of WindowSettings as the parent.

Something like this:

In WindowSettings:

private void showDialogSettings_Click(object sender, EventArgs e)
{
    var dialogSettingsCancel = new DialogSettingsCancel();
    dialogSettingsCancel.OwningWindowSettings = this;
    dialogSettingsCancel.Show();
}

In DialogSettingsCancel:

public WindowSettings OwningWindowSettings { get; set; }

private void button1_Click(object sender, EventArgs e)
{
    this.Close();
    if(OwningWindowSettings != null)
        OwningWindowSettings.Close();
}

This approach takes into account, that a DialogSettingsCancel could potentially be opened without a WindowsSettings as parent.

If the two are always connected, you should instead use a constructor parameter:

In WindowSettings:

private void showDialogSettings_Click(object sender, EventArgs e)
{
    var dialogSettingsCancel = new DialogSettingsCancel(this);
    dialogSettingsCancel.Show();
}

In DialogSettingsCancel:

WindowSettings _owningWindowSettings;

public DialogSettingsCancel(WindowSettings owningWindowSettings)
{
    if(owningWindowSettings == null)
        throw new ArgumentNullException("owningWindowSettings");

    _owningWindowSettings = owningWindowSettings;
}

private void button1_Click(object sender, EventArgs e)
{
    this.Close();
    _owningWindowSettings.Close();
}