Question

(PostgreSQL 8.4)
Table “trackingMessages” stores tracking events between mobile devices (tm_nl_mobileid) and fixed devices (tm_nl_fixedId).

CREATE TABLE trackingMessages
(
  tm_id SERIAL PRIMARY KEY,           -- PK
  tm_nl_mobileId INTEGER,             -- FK to mobile
  tm_nl_fixedId INTEGER,              -- FK to fixed
  tm_date INTEGER,                    -- Network time
  tm_messageType INTEGER,             -- 0=disconnect, 1=connect
  CONSTRAINT tm_unique_row
    UNIQUE (tm_nl_mobileId, tm_nl_fixedId, tm_date, tm_messageType)
);

Problem here is that it’s possible that the same mobile will connect to the same fixed twice (or more times) subsequently. I don’t want to see the subsequent ones, but it’s OK to see a mobile connected to a same fixed at a later date, provided there was a connection to a different fixed in between.

I think I’m close but not quite. I’ve been using the following CTE (found here on Stack Overflow)

WITH cte AS 
(
  SELECT tm_nl_fixedid, tm_date, Row_number() OVER (
    partition BY tm_nl_fixedid
    ORDER BY tm_date ASC
  ) RN 
  FROM   trackingMessages
) 
SELECT * FROM cte 
  WHERE tm_nl_mobileid = 150 AND tm_messagetype = 1
  ORDER BY tm_date;

Gives me the following results

32;1316538756;1
21;1316539069;1
32;1316539194;2
32;1316539221;3
21;1316539235;2

The problem here is that the last column should be 1, 1, 1, 2, 1, because that third “32” is in fact a duplicate tracking event (twice in a row at the same fixed) and that last connection to “21” is OK because “32” was in between.

Please don’t suggest a cursor, this is what I am currently trying to move away from. The cursor solution does work, but it’s too slow given the amount of records I have to deal with. I’d much rather fix the CTE and only select where RN = 1 … unless you have a better idea!

Answer 1

Well, you’re not that close because row_number() cannot track sequences by two groups at the same time. PARTITION BY tm_nl_fixedid ORDER BY date RESTART ON GAP does not exist, there’s no such thing.

Itzik Ben-Gan has a solution for the islands and gaps problem you are facing (several solutions, actually). The idea is to order rows by the main criteria (date) and then by partitioning criteria + main criteria. Difference between ordinals will remain the same as they belong to the same partitioning criteria and date series.

with cte as
(
  select *,
      -- While order by date and order by something-else, date
      -- run along, they belong to the same sequence
         row_number() over (order by tm_date)
       - row_number() over (order by tm_nl_fixedid, tm_date) grp
    from trackingMessages
)
select *,
    -- Now we can get ordinal number grouped by each sequence
       row_number() over (partition by tm_nl_fixedid, grp
                          order by tm_date) rn
  from cte
 order by tm_date

Here is Sql Fiddle with example.

And here is chapter 5 of Sql Server MVP Deep Dives with several solutions to islands and gaps problem.