Question

Say I have an ArrayList<B> array of objects from a certain class B, which extends A. B has an instance field bb and A a field aa. I know that saving array to a .dat-file using ObjectOutputStream requires that B (not just ArrayList!) implement Serializable. I’ve found, however, that when loading the object back from the file (using an ObjectInputStream):

 arrayLoaded = (ArrayList<B>)myObjIn.readObject();

the loaded array isn’t identical to the original array: In the particular case, arrayLoaded.get(0).bb has the same value as in array, but arrayLoaded.get(0).aa is “zeroed”. It has a default initialization value, regardless of its value when array was saved to file. However, this problem is solved by letting also A implement Serializable.

What bothers me is that this error is so subtle: no exception, no warning (in eclipse), nothing. Is there a reason for this or is this simply an oversight by the java developers? Do I just have to accept it and think hard about which classes in the hierarchy implement Serializable every time I want to use object IO streams?

Answer 1

Just because B implements Serializable, that does not retroactively include the fields of the non-serializable superclass in what gets serialized. (This makes sense, especially when you consider that being able to serialize private and package-private fields of any class just by extending it and implementing Serializable would violate its encapsulation.)

A field declared in A will behave the same as a field declared as transient in B. There is a workaround however. From the documentation for Serializable:

To allow subtypes of non-serializable classes to be serialized, the
subtype may assume responsibility for saving and restoring the state
of the supertype’s public, protected, and (if accessible) package
fields. The subtype may assume this responsibility only if the class
it extends has an accessible no-arg constructor to initialize the
class’s state.

So you will need to implement writeObject and readObject in B to handle the serialization/deserialization of A.aa.