Question

Simple and fast question, i have those tables:

//table people
| pe_id | pe_name |
| 1  | Foo  |
| 2  | Bar  |
//orders table
| ord_id | pe_id | ord_title   |
|   1    |   1   | First order |
|   2    |   2   | Order two   |
|   3    |   2   | Third order |
//items table
| item_id | ord_id | pe_id | title  |
|   1     |   1    |   1   | Apple  |
|   2     |   1    |   1   | Pear   |
|   3     |   2    |   2   | Apple  |
|   4     |   3    |   2   | Orange |
|   5     |   3    |   2   | Coke   |
|   6     |   3    |   2   | Cake   |

I need to have a query listing all the people, counting the number of orders and the total number of items, like that:

| pe_name | num_orders | num_items |
| Foo  |    1       |   2       |
| Bar  |    2       |   4       |

But i can not make it work!
I tried

SELECT
    people.pe_name,
    COUNT(orders.ord_id) AS num_orders,
    COUNT(items.item_id) AS num_items
FROM
    people
    INNER JOIN orders ON (orders.pe_id = people.pe_id)
    INNER JOIN items ON items.pe_id = people.pe_id
GROUP BY
    people.pe_id;

But this returns the num_* values incorrect:

| name | num_orders | num_items |
| Foo  |    2       |   2       |
| Bar  |    8       |   8       |

I noticed that if i try to join one table at time, it works:

SELECT
    people.pe_name,
    COUNT(orders.ord_id) AS num_orders
FROM
    people
    INNER JOIN orders ON (orders.pe_id = people.pe_id)
GROUP BY
    people.pe_id;

//give me:
| pe_name | num_orders |
| Foo     |          1 |
| Bar     |          2 |

//and:
SELECT
    people.pe_name,
    COUNT(items.item_id) AS num_items
FROM
    people
    INNER JOIN items ON (items.pe_id = people.pe_id)
GROUP BY
    people.pe_id;
//output:
| pe_name | num_items |
| Foo     |         2 |
| Bar     |         4 |

How to combine those two queries in one?

Answer 1

It makes more sense to join the item with the orders than with the people !

SELECT
    people.pe_name,
    COUNT(distinct orders.ord_id) AS num_orders,
    COUNT(items.item_id) AS num_items
FROM
    people
    INNER JOIN orders ON orders.pe_id = people.pe_id
         INNER JOIN items ON items.ord_id = orders.ord_id
GROUP BY
    people.pe_id;

Joining the items with the people provokes a lot of doublons.
For example, the cake items in order 3 will be linked with the order 2 via the join between the people, and you don’t want this to happen !!

So :

1- You need a good understanding of your schema. Items are link to orders, and not to people.

2- You need to count distinct orders for one person, else you will count as many items as orders.