Question

The following code compiles and it seems to run fine:

class Test {
  private:
     const unsigned MAX;

  public:

     Test (const unsigned int n) : MAX(n) { }

     void foo () {
         int array[MAX];
         ...
     }

};

but is it really OK? I mean:

Test a (3);
Test b (8);

does array actually have 3 and 8 cells respectively?

If so, is it because array is an automatic var and gets instantiated with the appropriate dimension?

Thanks

Answer 1

What you have written is valid in c99 but not valid c++.

I am of course talking about your use of VLA‘s, not the full snippet.

---

When compiling using g++ -pedantic -ansi -Wall we get the below warning;

foo.cpp: In member function 'void Test::foo()':
foo.cpp:18:23: warning: ISO C++ forbids variable length array 'array' [-Wvla]

---

As mentioned in the above warning the pattern you are using is often referred to as using a variable length array, which is standard in C99 and “allowed” in C++ through a g++ extension.

I’d recommend you to use a STL container instead of hacks as these, for one single reason; what you are doing is not legal, and therefor isn’t guaranteed to be portable cross compilers.