Question

The following declaration in C:

int* a, b;

will declare a as type int* and b as type int. I’m well aware of this trap, but what I want to know is why it works this way. Why doesn’t it also declare b as int*, as most people would intuitively expect? In other words, why does * apply to the variable name, rather than the type?

Sure you could write it this way to be more consistent with how it actually works:

int *a, b;

However, I and everyone I’ve spoken to think in terms of a is of type “pointer to int”, rather than a is a pointer to some data and the type of that data is “int”.

Was this simply a bad decision by the designers of C or is there some good reason why it’s parsed this way? I’m sure the question has been answered before, but I can’t seem to find it using the search.

Answer 1

There’s a web page on The Development of the C Language that says, “The syntax of these declarations reflects the observation that i, *pi, and **ppi all yield an int type when used in an expression.” Search for that sentence on the page to find the relevant section that talks about this question.