Question

There are 3 modifiers: @private, @protected (default) and @public. So if i define a instance variable as private then that should not be accessible from anywhere.
For E.g. –

@interface A {
    @private
    NSString *a;
}
@property(nonatomic, retain) NSString *a;

Now inside implementation of some other interface/class B-

-(void)getSomeValue {
     A *object = [[A alloc] init];
     NSString *value = object.a;
     .........
 }

Here i am able to access instance variable, although i defined that as private.

It is a bit confusing, although when i look into details of this statement, then it is clear that it is calling the getter of a, but then also it seems confusing and it is against the concept of OOPS.

Anyone having any thought on this?

Answer 1

It’s not the instance variable you’re accessing but the property you declared. Don’t declare the property if you do not want the instance variable to be visible outside the class.