Question

This one doesn’t want to compile:

class MainClass
{
public:
    ...

private:
    class NestedClass
    { //Line 39
        ...
    };

    class NestedClass * getNestedClassFor(int i);
};

The compiler says:

error: ‘class MainClass::NestedClass’ is private

However, if I made NestedClass public, it would work.

Why doesn’t it work? It’s not as though I’m exporting a nested class through a public method? It’s just a private method returning a pointer to a private class. Any ideas?

Thanks!

Update

Fixed the semi-columns. They’re not the problem. Neither is writing class in front of NestedClass.

Here’s the error message:

MainClass.h: In function ‘MainClass::NestedClass* getNestedClassFor(int i)’:

MainClass.h:39: error: ‘class MainClass::NestedClass’ is private

MainClass.cpp:49: error: within this context

Here’s the part of the .cpp file that’s also complaining:

class MainClass::NestedClass * getNestedClassFor(int i) //Line 49
{
    return NULL;
}

Answer 1

Had forgotten to add the class scope in the .cpp, i.e.

class MainClass::NestedClass * getNestedClassFor(int i)
{
   //...
}

Should be

class MainClass::NestedClass * MainClass::getNestedClassFor(int i)
{
   //...
}

Stupid me!