Question

This should be and easy one for the LINQ gurus out there.

I’m doing a complex Query using UNIONS and CONTAINSTABLE in my database to return ranked results to my application.

I’m getting duplicates in my returned data. This is expected. I’m using CONTAINSTABLE and CONTAINS to get all the results I need. CONTAINSTABLE is ranked by SQL and CONTAINS (which is run only on the Keywords field ) is hard-code-ranked by me. ( Sorry if that doesn’t make sense )

Anyway, because the tuples aren’t identical ( their rank is different ) a duplicate is returned.

I figure the best way to deal with this is use LINQ.

I know I’ll be using the Distinct() extension method, but do I have to implement the IEqualityComparer interface? I’m a little fuzzy on how to do this.

For argument’s sake, say my resultset is structured like this class:

class Content {
  ContentID int //KEY
  Rank int 
  Description String 
}

If I have a List<Content> how would I write the Distinct() method to exclude Rank? Ideally I’d like to keep the Content’s highest Rank. SO, if one Content’s RAnk is 112 and the other is 76. I’d like to keep the 112 rank.

Hopefully I’ve given enough information.

EDIT

Here’s a sample of the SQL for anyone who has an Idea on how to do this in SQL:

UNION ALL  
SELECT
    p.ProductID     AS ContentID
  , p.ProductName   AS Title
  , K.RANK          AS Rank
  , 'Product'       AS ContentType
  , p.AddedDateTime

FROM Products AS p
 INNER JOIN CONTAINSTABLE(NaturalFactorsPIM.dbo.Products,*, @SearchPred, @TopN) AS K ON K.[KEY] = P.ProductID
WHERE @IncludeProducts = 1 
  AND p.ProductStatus = 1 

UNION ALL  
SELECT
   p.ProductID    AS ContentID
 , p.ProductName  AS Title
 , 80             AS Rank
 , 'Product'      AS ContentType
 , p.AddedDateTime

FROM Products AS p
WHERE FREETEXT( p.ProductKeywords, @SearchPred)
  AND @IncludeProducts = 1 
  AND p.ProductStatus = 1 

ORDER BY Rank DESC

Answer 1

This should do what you want:

Var List<Content> AllTheData = GetTheDataForThisExample()
Var DistinctDataWithMaxRank = From C in AllTheData
    Group C by C.ContentID, C.Description
         Into G
    Select New { ContentID = g.ContentID
                 Rank = (From rmax in g select rmax.rank).Max()
                 Description = g.Description
               };

But, if I understand you correctly, this would be very easy in SQL:

Select ContentID, Max(Rank) As Rank, Description
From (Select * From ComplicatedFullTextSearchQuery()) As Q
Group By ContentID, Description

I arranged this sql like your main query was a UDF; whatever your original query is, put it in the () on the second line. If performance matters, have a procedure/function put your original query into a temporary table, an then just do:

Select ContentID, Max(Rank) As Rank, Description
From TempTable    Group By ContentID, Description