Question

We’re working on a Ruby on Rails app that needs to take advantage of html5 websockets. At the moment, we have two separate “servers” so to speak: our main app running on nginx+passenger, and a separate server using Pratik Naik’s Cramp framework (which is running on Thin) to handle the websocket connections.

Ideally, when it comes time for deployment, we’d have the rails app running on nginx+passenger, and the websocket server would be proxied behind nginx, so we wouldn’t need to have the websocket server running on a different port.

Problem is, in this setup it seems that nginx is closing the connections to Thin too early. The connection is successfully established to the Thin server, then immediately closed with a 200 response code. Our guess is that nginx doesn’t realize that the client is trying to establish a long-running connection for websocket traffic.

Admittedly, I’m not all that savvy with nginx config, so, is it even possible to configure nginx to act as a reverse proxy for a websocket server? Or do I have to wait for nginx to offer support for the new websocket handshake stuff? Assuming that having both the app server and the websocket server listening on port 80 is a requirement, might that mean I have to have Thin running on a separate server without nginx in front for now?

Thanks in advance for any advice or suggestions. 🙂

-John

Answer 1

You can’t use nginx for this currently^{[it’s not true anymore]}, but I would suggest looking at HAProxy. I have used it for exactly this purpose.

The trick is to set long timeouts so that the socket connections are not closed. Something like:

timeout client  86400000 # In the frontend
timeout server  86400000 # In the backend

If you want to serve say a rails and cramp application on the same port you can use ACL rules to detect a websocket connection and use a different backend. So your haproxy frontend config would look something like

frontend all 0.0.0.0:80
  timeout client    86400000
  default_backend   rails_backend
  acl websocket hdr(Upgrade)    -i WebSocket
  use_backend   cramp_backend   if websocket

For completeness the backend would look like

backend cramp_backend
  timeout server  86400000
  server cramp1 localhost:8090 maxconn 200 check