Question

What is the difference between declaring a field as val, lazy val and object inside a scala class, as in the following snippet:

class A

class B {
  val a1 = new A      { def foo = 1 }
  object a2 extends A { def foo = 1 }
  lazy val a3 = new A { def foo = 1 }
}

Answer 1

In the former, any code included is executed as soon as class B is created. In the latter, however, until you actually use the object, it won’t be instantiated.

You can see the difference here:

class A { println("Creating a new A") }
class B {
  val a1 = new A { println("a1"); def foo = 1 }
  object a2 extends A { println("a2"); def foo = 1 }
}

scala> val b = new B
Creating a new A
a1
b: B = B@1176e8a

scala> b.a2.foo
Creating a new A
a2
res0: Int = 1

There are also hidden differences in what the created .class files are named and such; and of course the two have different types.