Question

When calling Any() on a null object, it throws an ArgumentNullException in C#. If the object is null, there definitely aren’t ‘any’, and it should probably return false.

Why does C# behave this way?

Answer 1

When dealing with reference types, a null value is semantically different from an “empty” value.

A null string is not the same as string.Empty, and a null IEnumerable<T> is not the same as Enumerable.Empty<T> (or any other “empty” enumerable of that type).

If Any were not an extension method, calling it on null would result in NullReferenceException. Since it is an extension method, throwing some exception (although not necessary) is a good idea because it preserves the well-known semantics of trying to call a method on null: BOOM!