Question

When defining a method on a class in Python, it looks something like this:

class MyClass(object):     def __init__(self, x, y):         self.x = x         self.y = y 

But in some other languages, such as C#, you have a reference to the object that the method is bound to with the ‘this’ keyword without declaring it as an argument in the method prototype.

Was this an intentional language design decision in Python or are there some implementation details that require the passing of ‘self’ as an argument?

Answer 1

I like to quote Peters’ Zen of Python. ‘Explicit is better than implicit.’

In Java and C++, ‘this.‘ can be deduced, except when you have variable names that make it impossible to deduce. So you sometimes need it and sometimes don’t.

Python elects to make things like this explicit rather than based on a rule.

Additionally, since nothing is implied or assumed, parts of the implementation are exposed. self.__class__, self.__dict__ and other ‘internal’ structures are available in an obvious way.