Home/ Questions/Q 538439
In Process

The Archive Base Latest Questions

Editorial Team
  • 0
Asked: 2026-05-13T10:01:55+00:00

When I write SQL queries, I find myself often thinking that there’s no way

  • 0

When I write SQL queries, I find myself often thinking that “there’s no way to do this with a single query”. When that happens I often turn to stored procedures or multi-statement table-valued functions that use temp tables (of one sort or another) and end up simply combining the results and returning the result table.

I’m wondering if anyone knows, simply as a matter of theory, whether it should be possible to write ANY query that returns a single result set as a single query (not multiple statements). Obviously, I’m ignoring relevant points such as code readability and maintainability, maybe even query performance/efficiency. This is more about theory – can it be done… and don’t worry, I certainly don’t plan to start forcing myself to write a single-statement query when multi-statement will better suit my purpose in all cases, but it might make me think twice or a little bit longer on whether there is a viable way to get the result from a single query.

I guess a few parameters are in order – I’m thinking of a relational database (such as MS SQL) with tables that follow common best practices (such as all tables having a primary key and so forth).

Note: in order to win ‘Accepted Answer’ on this, you’ll need to provide a definitive proof (reference to web material or something similar.)

Share

Leave an answer

You must login to add an answer.

Need An Account,

1 Answer

  1. Editorial Team

    At least with the a recent version of Oracle is absolutely possible. It has a ‘model clause’ which makes sql turing complete. ( http://blog.schauderhaft.de/2009/06/18/building-a-turing-engine-in-oracle-sql-using-the-model-clause/ ). Of course this is all with the usual limitation that we don’t really have unlimited time and memory.

    For a normal sql dialect without these abdominations I don’t think it is possible.

    A task that I can’t see how to implement in ‘normal sql’ would be:
    Assume a table with a single column of type integer

    For every row
    ‘take the value at the current row and go that many rows back, fetch that value, go that many rows back, and continue until you fetch the same value twice consecutively and return that as the result.’

    • 0