Question

I am reading a book – ASP.Net 3.5 Enterprise Application Development with Visual Studio 2008 and when it talks about updating a record in the database using Linq-to-SQL it uses this code:

MyUserAccount ua = new MyUserAccount
{
... Update fields
};

ua.UserAccountID = Convert.ToInt32(session["UserAccountID"]);
ua.Version = Convert.ToInt32(session["Version"]);

MyDataContext db = new MyDataContext();
db.MyUserAccounts.Attach(ua,true);
db.SubmitChanges();

Versus what I am used to, where I just save the AccountID in a session variable
and then get the record from the database, make my changes, and then submit the changes.

BtnUpdate

int UserAccountID = Convert.ToInt32(Request["UserAccountID"]);

//Get User fron Context
MyDataContext db = new MyDataContext();
MyUserAccount ua = db.MyUserAccounts.Single(
     x => x.UserAccountID == UserAccountID);

//Make changes
ua.Blah = "";

db.SubmitChanges();

So my question is what is the preferred way to do this? Having not seen this in the past I am not sure what the preferred or best way is. Any help is appreciated.

Wade

Note:

My original question, someone changed my title, was what was the best Linq-to-SQL way to update the record. So I changed the code to use session variables and the title back to it’s original. Please, read the whole question as I am only looking for the best method to update my record in the database using Linq-to-SQL.

Answer 1

In terms of sql produced the former will generate a Sql statement something like

Update MyUserAccount set blah=@Blah where UserAccountID = @UserAccountID

whereas the latter will produce

Select UserAccountID, Blah, ....  From MyUserAccount where UserAccountID = @UserAccountID
Update MyUserAccount set blah=@Blah where UserAccountID = @UserAccountID