Question

I have this piece of code that loads Properties from a file:

class Config {
  val properties: Properties = {
    val p = new Properties()
    p.load(Thread.currentThread().getContextClassLoader.getResourceAsStream("props"))
    p
  }

  val forumId = properties.get("forum_id")
}

This seems to be working fine.

I have tried moving the initialization of properties into another val, loadedProperties, like this:

class Config {
  val properties: Properties = loadedProps
  val forumId = properties.get("forum_id")

  private val loadedProps = {
    val p = new Properties()
    p.load(Thread.currentThread().getContextClassLoader.getResourceAsStream("props"))
    p 
   }

}

But it doesn’t work! (properties is null in properties.get("forum_id") ).

Why would that be? Isn’t loadedProps evaluated when referenced by properties?

Secondly, is this a good way to initialize variables that require non-trivial processing? In Java, I would declare them final fields, and do the initialization-related operations in the constructor.

Is there a pattern for this scenario in Scala?

Thank you!

Answer 1

Vals are initialized in the order they are declared (well, precisely, non-lazy vals are), so properties is getting initialized before loadedProps. Or in other words, loadedProps is still null when propertiesis getting initialized.
The simplest solution here is to define loadedProps before properties:

class Config {
  private val loadedProps = {
    val p = new Properties()
    p.load(Thread.currentThread().getContextClassLoader.getResourceAsStream("props"))
    p 
  }
  val properties: Properties = loadedProps
  val forumId = properties.get("forum_id")
}

You could also make loadedProps lazy, meaning that it will be initialized on its first access:

class Config {
  val properties: Properties = loadedProps
  val forumId = properties.get("forum_id")

  private lazy val loadedProps = {
    val p = new Properties()
    p.load(Thread.currentThread().getContextClassLoader.getResourceAsStream("props"))
    p 
  }
}

Using lazy val has the advantage that your code is more robust to refactoring, as merely changing the declaration order of your vals won’t break your code.

Also in this particular occurence, you can just turn loadedProps into a def (as suggested by @NIA) as it is only used once anyway.