Question

I recently had a discussion on another forum with another developer and the topic was Code Reuse in ASP.NET. The stated scenario was that he needs to update code frequently on Production servers during server uptimes, and this results in Session getting reset for all users. He is avoiding putting shared code or classes into the App_Code folder or precompiled DLL’s into the Bin folder because any updates will also refresh the Session.

The solution he has come up with is to put his shared code into UserControls and reference them wherever required. This enables him to update only the UserControl files which would be recompiled dynamically on next request without forcing a Session restart. Note that the Usercontrols are not intended to have any UI, they probably only house some business logic.

I tried to convince him against this because it felt intrinsically wrong to me – but I could not provide any hard facts to support my claim that this was a very bad way of doing things. The only thing I could think of is that it violates the principle of separation of business logic from UI. Am I grossly mistaken or are there concrete reasons why this should not be done? Links or examples would be helpful.

Note: Using out-of-process Session state is not an option at present, nor have they been able to decide on scheduled downtimes. Also, since this is a site under active development, they don’t seem to be using any sort of professional deployment model yet.

Thanks in advance.

Edit: Additionally, it would be helpful if someone could clarify exactly why the Session restarts in the above mentioned cases.

Answer 1

It does seem like an unusual approach, and persistent session is the obvious answer. Assuming that reasons not to use persistent session are legitimate, sometime you just have to go with whatever works. I’d make a point of clearly documenting in the source files the unusual use of usercontrols and live with it.

To answer the why does session get reset edit. With in process session all the session data is in memory as part of your application. Various changes to the web site (e.g. web.config and others I don’t recall off the top of my head) cause the application to restart wiping out all current state in your application. Persisting to SQL or the out of process session state server would allow the application to reset and lose any state without affecting the session data.