If I have a class, which has dual dependencies on the same type (needs

Question

0

Asked: May 30, 20262026-05-30T07:13:47+00:00 2026-05-30T07:13:47+00:00

If I have a class, which has dual dependencies on the same type (needs

0

If I have a class, which has dual dependencies on the same type (needs two different instances), if the only difference between the instances is a deeper dependency, what’s the best way to have Ninject perform DI and keep the two graphs separate?

Example object graph:

foo → ClassA → ClassB
bar → ClassA → ClassB

Class C‘s constructor:

public class C
{
    public C(ClassB foo, ClassB bar) { … }
}

So how do I make sure that the ClassB instantiated with foo gets supplied as the ClassB dependancy foo, and bar… bar?

Just for some background, I had some requirements change, so I need to replace a write-only repository (IAdd) with a composite write-only repository

public class CompositeWriteRepository<T> : IAdd<T>
{
    public CompositeWriteRepository(IAdd<T> foo, IAdd<T> bar, Func<T, bool> descriminator) { ... }
    public Add(T entity)
    {
        if (descriminator(entity)) {
            foo.Add(entity);
        } else {
            bar.Add(entity);
        }
    }        
}

With mocking, that was easy enough, I could just inject using names:

 kernel.Bind<IAdd<EntityType>>().To<fooRepository>().Named("foo");
 kernel.Bind<IAdd<EntityType>>().To<barRepository>().Named("bar");

 kernel.Bind<IAdd<EntityType>>().To<CompositeWriterRepository<EntityType>>()
    .WithConstructorArgument("foo", x => x.Kernel.Get<IAdd<EntityType>>("foo")
    .WithConstructorArgument("bar", x => x.Kernel.Get<IAdd<EntityType>>("bar");

The problem comes when I use the real repositories; foo and bar ultimately write to files so they need different file names. Since they’re StreamWriter repositories, one of their dependencies actually gets the two different file names.

string FileName → FileStreamWriterFactory → StreamRepository → CompositeRepository

The only way I’ve found thus far to construct things is to make a named FileName, named FileStreamWriterFactory, named StreamRepository × 2 (once for foo and once for bar). This seems like a lot of work, so I hope there’s a better solution.

I can re-architect if needed, it felt like an elegant way to quickly add in seperating the entries when the requirements changed. I realize my classes all are quite specific, but I think single responsibility would support this generally and in my case we write a bunch of small applications and have more requests the we can fulfill so its a good way to have lot’s of re-usable code laying around that I basically just need to re-configure for different tasks.

Solution
Remo Gloor should get credit; his is probably the best practice.

What I actually did was create a new extension

public static bool WhenAnchester(this IRequest request, Func<IRequest, bool> conditions)
{
    var parentContext = request.ParentContext;
    if (parentContext == null) {
            return false;
    }

    return conditions(parentContext.Request) || 
        parentContext.Request.WhenAnchester(conditions);
}

This then let me easily control which file get injected into which repository.

kernel.Bind<string>().ToConstant("Foo.txt")
    .When(x => x.Target.Name == "filepath" && 
              x.WhenAnchester(t => t.Target != null && t.Target.Name == "Dest1"));

kernel.Bind<string>().ToConstant("Bar.txt")
    .When(x => x.Target.Name == "filepath" &&
               x.WhenAnchester(t => t.Target != null && t.Target.Name == "Dest2"));

There’s probably a better solution, so I wouldn’t necessary recommend this for others, but its working well for me.