What is the best way for multiple client programs to
communicate with a single server program, all running
on a single Windows computer? All written in VB6.
I’d appreciate recommendations of how you might solve
this problem.
NOTE: we are working on transition to .NET, but have to
add a capability to the V6B version before the .NET will
be ready.
The possibilities include TPC connections, named pipes,
shared memory, messages, files, and more.
A client passes the server a string as input, and the server
combines it with data known only to the server, to generate
another string which is returned to the client. Both strings
are only about 100 characters long. The server is contacted
only when a new file needs to be opened, and so it is a very
low volume of communication… probably a flurry of 10 calls
within 15 seconds, followed by an hour of idle time.
But it is possible that two clients would choose about the
same time to request information. Blocking/Locking are certainly
acceptable, as the server will be done with each request in
well under a second, and several seconds of delay is unimportant
to any of the programs.
The server’s algorithm is complex, and for several reasons important
to the application should not be replicated in each helper program.
That is the reason for needing a server.
Background:
I am adding capability to a large existing legacy program.
This single program has several other legacy programs which
act as helpers and are run when the user makes certain
choices. These programs are started with a shell command,
and are not just separate threads. For instance, one helper
loads new data from a DVD drive onto the hard drive. Another
helper just displays a chart of the current positions of
the planets.
This is a LARGE commercial legacy program that happens to be
written in VB6. We are working to convert it and all the
helper programs to .NET, but must first release a new version
under vb6 with this added capability. (Please don’t tell me
to not use VB6, as we are already moving elsewhere.)
We need a temporary VB6 solution.
For a one-off upgrade release to an existing VB6 application being moved to a newer platform, I would stress keeping the modification as simple and straightforward as possible. As a result, I wouldn’t go down any routes involving shared memory or anything relatively unusual.
A few options, none perfectly simple, but at least some ideas:
Expose a COM object in the server code that performs the translation, and can be consumed by the client apps. The clients instantiate the object from the server as an out-of-process object, and let COM handle all the marshalling, etc.
Does the server have any network awareness? VB6 doesn’t do sockets/tcp natively very well, but if you’ve had a reason to add that in, you might be able to leverage it to perform a socket-based connection and data exchange.
The server and client could each poll a common resource folder for the presence of a specific file that constituted inbound/outbound requests for the translation service you describe. Not very elegant, but it might be the simplest.
Just a few ideas to give you some things to think about. Hope that’s helpful in some way. Good luck!