Question

When we have anything that requires user input (Eg adding a product to a database) the Edit screen looks the same as the add screen. When using MVC .Net how do you handle this? Do you return the same view? Just adjust the model to reflect the change?

Answer 1

Same (partial)view

You create only one but strong typed view (depending on the UI it can of course be a partial view as well). When adding new data return this view from controller action with default model object instance (usually just a new instance without any properties being set), but when you edit, return it with the object instance that you’d like to edit.

Controller part

Regarding controller actions you can have four of them:

1. Add GET
   return View("SomeView", new Customer());
2. Add POST
3. Edit GET
   return View("SomeView", new CustomerRepository().GetCustomer(id));
4. Edit POST

Bot GET actions return the same view but with different model as described earlier. POST actions both store submitted data, but return whatever they need to. Probably some RedirectToAction()…